I hooked up Prometheus to our new Grafana Cloud instance, following the directions here: Hooking Up Fly Metrics · The Fly Blog. When I “Save and test,” I get a green check mark and the service is reported as OK.
Ah hah! That was it – I was using https://api.fly.io/prometheus/personal as that’s what the blog post says to use, but I see now that I should replace personal in that URL with the Fly.io org name.
Someone should probably update the post to point that out!
Anyway, looks like everything is working now, thanks!